A practical, Indonesia-specific playbook to set up and pass MSC/ASC mass balance (neraca massa) in 90 days. Includes simple reconciliation math for shrimp and tuna, audit-ready records, and a rollout plan your plant team can actually follow.
If you run a mixed plant in Indonesia, mass balance is the Chain of Custody control system that lets you handle certified and non‑certified seafood together and still make legitimate MSC/ASC claims. We’ve implemented neraca massa repeatedly across Indonesian facilities. The pattern is the same: keep the math simple, keep the records tight, and train your team on when they can and can’t make claims. Here’s the actionable version we wish we’d had on day one.
The 3 pillars of a bulletproof mass balance system
-
Map the flow before you do the math. Walk the raw‑to‑finished flow, including rework, trimming, WIP, subcontracted steps and cold stores. Where can certified and non‑certified co‑mingle? What’s physically lost to moisture, glaze removal, drip loss or cooking? Draw it.
-
Lock yields and conversions, then lock the period. Mass balance is period‑based reconciliation. Fix your reconciliation period (weekly for high‑volume lines, monthly for stable ones) and fix the conversion factors for each product form in that period. Update yields only after a controlled review. Auditors hate shifting baselines.
-
Claims management beats everything. Only allocate MSC/ASC claims to outputs up to the certified‑equivalent volume available. Labeling and invoices must match the allocation. When in doubt, don’t claim.
Takeaway: If you can explain your flow on one page and show the numbers in one sheet, you’re 80% of the way there.
Week 1–2: Map, train, and set up the templates
Start with a gemba walk. Intake, grading, trimming, glazing, packing, cold store, dispatch, subcontractors. Note every place product can gain/lose weight.
Set up a single Mass Balance Register for each species and form. Minimum columns we use:
- Period, Product form, Species, Site/line
- Certified input qty and supplier CoC code
- Non‑certified input qty
- Standard yield or conversion factor (net weight, no glaze)
- Outputs by SKU, including WIP, rework and waste
- Claimed output qty (MSC/ASC), Unclaimed output qty
- Running balance of certified‑equivalent volume
- Notes on adjustments and approvals
Train your intake, production, and sales teams on three things: how to capture certificate scope/claim on intake docs, how to record waste and non‑conforming product, and how to block claims when the balance is zero.
Tools we’ve found reliable: a locked Excel or Google Sheets template with data validation and pivot summaries. If you’re already on ERP, create a dedicated mass balance dashboard. You don’t need fancy software to pass, but you do need discipline.
Need a quick sanity check on your setup? If you want us to review your spreadsheet and do a dry‑run reconciliation, contact us on whatsapp.
Week 3–6: Pilot on one line and reconcile weekly
Pick a clean pilot. For many plants, shrimp portions or tuna steaks work well.
Shrimp example (ASC or MSC CoC scope): You intake 5,000 kg MSC‑certified Vannamei HLSO and 7,000 kg non‑certified in Week 1. You convert to PUD finished. Your approved yield is 65% net (no glaze). Certified‑equivalent output capacity = 5,000 × 0.65 = 3,250 kg PUD. Across all PUD produced that week, the maximum you can allocate as MSC is 3,250 kg. If you packed 4,000 kg PUD total, you can claim MSC on 3,250 kg and the remaining 750 kg must be sold unclaimed. If you applied 10% glaze, remember to compute on net weight. We see over‑allocation happen when teams accidentally include glaze.
Tuna example: You process mixed Yellowfin Steak and Yellowfin Ground Meat (IQF). You intake 3,000 kg certified loins and 3,000 kg non‑certified loins. Your week’s outputs are 2,400 kg steaks at 80% yield and 2,400 kg ground meat at 80% yield. Certified‑equivalent capacity = 3,000 × 0.80 = 2,400 kg. You can allocate any combination of steak and ground meat up to 2,400 kg as MSC. Many plants choose to claim steaks first for margin, leaving ground meat unclaimed.
Practical checks during the pilot:
- Reconcile every Friday before issuing any MSC/ASC claim on sales docs.
- Run a 10‑minute internal trace: pick one claimed SKU and trace intake docs, production batch, and balance line.
- Verify supplier certificates are valid and in scope on the day of receipt. Screenshot or download copies to your file.
Week 7–12: Scale, optimize, and harden for audit
Once the pilot passes two clean reconciliations, add adjacent SKUs. Bake in controls that catch the usual mistakes.
- Add species and cut forms prone to co‑mingling, like Frozen Shrimp (Black Tiger, Vannamei & Wild Caught) and Skipjack Cube (WGGS / IQF).
- Lock label approval: on‑product MSC ecolabel requires a license and approved artwork. Under mass balance you can allocate claims to indistinguishable outputs, but only label the allocated volume and only after artwork approval. When unsure, use B2B text claims on paperwork instead of the on‑pack ecolabel.
- Multi‑site or subcontracting? Central office aggregates certified balance per site and period. Any subcontracted packer or cold store handling claimed product must either be in your CoC scope or hold their own. If not, treat outputs as non‑certified for claim purposes.
We also build a simple batch‑coding rule: Species‑Date‑Line‑Sequence (for example, YF‑240315‑L2‑041). It makes internal traces painless.
What exactly is mass balance and when can Indonesian processors use it?
Mass balance allows processors to mix certified and non‑certified product and then allocate a proportional amount of outputs as certified, limited by certified inputs adjusted for yields. In Indonesia, it’s a strong fit when you have shared lines, variable grades, or rework. If you can segregate without cost or complexity, segregation is simpler. But if you run mixed Grouper Fillet (IQF) or tuna lines all day, mass balance keeps throughput high without building duplicate lines.
How do I calculate MSC mass balance for mixed shrimp batches?
Short version: Certified‑equivalent outputs = Certified inputs × Approved yield. Only allocate claims up to that number within the reconciliation period. Use net weight. Exclude glaze and packaging. Keep rework in the same period or document carryover clearly.
Can I make an MSC claim if I process certified and non‑certified tuna together?
Yes, under mass balance you can co‑process and then allocate claims to part of the output, as long as your certified‑equivalent balance is positive. You can’t claim beyond the certified balance, and you need valid supplier certificates, internal reconciliation, and correct claims on sales documents. For consumer‑facing ecolabel, get artwork approved under your license before printing.
What records do auditors check for mass balance in Indonesia?
From our audits, expect to show:
- Intake records with supplier CoC code, species, FAO area if applicable, and claim type.
- Copies or screenshots of valid supplier certificates and scope on receipt dates.
- Production records with yields, trimmings, WIP, rework and waste. Include moisture loss and de‑glazing steps if used.
- Mass balance register per species/form and period with running certified balance.
- Stock cards or ERP reports for claimed SKUs and unclaimed equivalents.
- Sales docs showing correct MSC/ASC claim text, your CoC code, and volumes not exceeding balance.
- Staff training records, internal trace tests, and corrective actions.
How often should we reconcile inputs and outputs?
Our rule: before any claim is issued. Operationally, weekly for high‑volume species and monthly for stable lines. Do a full period close with sign‑off by QA and Sales. Also reconcile after any abnormal event like a large rework, yield change, or subcontractor run.
Do subcontracted cold stores or packers need to be included?
If a subcontractor handles product that will carry an MSC/ASC claim, they must be included in your certificate scope or hold their own valid CoC with the right scope. If not, treat that product as non‑certified for claims. Declare and control subcontractors in your procedures and keep their records on file.
The 5 mistakes that kill mass balance audits (and how to avoid them)
- Over‑allocating because of glaze. Always calculate on net weight. Keep a de‑glazing SOP and test actual glaze.
- Using unapproved or expired supplier certificates. Validate scope and validity on the day of intake and archive proof.
- Changing yields mid‑period without approval. Freeze yields for the period. Review changes with signed rationale.
- Claiming after subcontractor handling that’s out of scope. Either include them or don’t claim.
- Sloppy claims on sales docs. Use standardized claim text and your CoC code. Block invoicing if the balance is zero.
Quick reference: Audit‑ready mass balance checklist
- One‑page flow map with all co‑mingling points and controls
- Period‑based mass balance register with running balances
- Approved yields per SKU and form, by period
- Intake docs with CoC references and certificate copies
- Production, WIP, rework, waste records linked to batches
- Sales docs with correct claim statements and artwork approvals (if on‑pack)
- Internal trace test records and staff training logs
What’s changed recently and what hasn’t
Auditors are leaning harder into digital trace tests and near‑real‑time reconciliation. Expect more sampling of negative balances, glaze deductions, and subcontractor controls. The fundamentals of mass balance math and documentation haven’t changed. Keep it simple, transparent, and timely.
If you want pragmatic help tailoring neraca massa to your lines or need a pre‑audit stress test, call us. And if you’re exploring supply options for certified‑capable species, you can also View our products to see Indonesian SKUs we already run under tight traceability.